Journal · Playbook
Seven Meta Ads settings to change in your first hour
Meta's ad defaults are built for a company that ships nationwide. If you sell to people who can drive to you, seven settings in Ads Manager decide whether your budget stays in your county.
A hair salon in Avon handed me a Meta ad account last month. $1,180 spent over nine weeks, 22 leads, $53 a lead. She wanted to know whether that was good.
It took ninety seconds to find the problem. Her ads had been delivering to people in four states.
Meta's defaults are built for a company that ships nationwide. Yours is a shop people drive to. Seven settings in Ads Manager decide which of those two businesses Meta thinks you are, and Meta points every one of them the wrong way out of the box. You can change all seven in about an hour, and none of them involve your photos or your headline.
Do these before you touch the creative.
Why do my Facebook ads reach people outside my area?
Because the location box has four options and Meta picks the widest one for you.
The default is People living in or recently in this location. "Recently in" means anyone whose phone has been inside your radius lately. For a shop on 86th Street, that includes every person who took the I-465 exit on their way to somewhere else.
Switch it to People living in this location. One click. For a salon, a dentist, a gym, an auto shop, or anything people come back to, that is the correct setting.
Then fix the radius. Meta's floor is one mile, and most local accounts I open are sitting far above it because nobody moved the slider. Set it by drive time rather than distance. A nail salon pulls from about twelve minutes. An HVAC contractor pulls from forty. A specialty bike shop pulls from an hour, because there are four of them in the state. Ask how far your last ten customers drove, then set the radius to that number and stop.
Advantage+ audience ignores most of what you typed
Advantage+ audience is on by default, and it sorts your inputs into two piles.
Hard controls: location, language, minimum age, exclusions, and special ad category. Meta stays inside those. Everything else is a suggestion, including your age range, gender, and every interest you spent twenty minutes picking. Meta overrides those whenever it thinks it can find a cheaper buyer somewhere else.
So the women aged 35 to 65 you selected are not a rule. Your one-mile radius is.
That split is not bad news by itself. Meta's targeting is better than yours at finding people who buy. It turns into bad news the moment you assume the interest field is a fence and build your budget around it. Set your minimum age on purpose and put your real service area in the location box. Treat the interest field as a hint you handed the machine.
Your ads are running inside mobile games
Advantage+ placements is also on by default, and it includes Audience Network: third-party apps and mobile games where your ad appears between levels.
Audience Network clicks are cheap, which is the trouble. A $0.14 click from someone who fat-fingered a banner in a puzzle game makes your cost-per-click column look excellent and sends you nobody.
Let Advantage+ placements run for two weeks, then open the placement breakdown in Ads Manager. If Audience Network is taking more than a fifth of your spend and producing no leads, switch to manual placements and keep four: Facebook Feed, Instagram Feed, Stories, and Reels.
Meta is editing your photos
Meta ships a set of Advantage+ creative enhancements switched on. Image expansion invents pixels to fill a placement it wasn't cropped for. Visual touch-ups shift your brightness and contrast. Image template drops a text bar across your photo. 3D animation makes a still drift. Music adds an auto-selected track to Reels and Stories. Text improvements move your headline somewhere Meta likes better.
For a shop that paid a photographer $400 for twelve pictures of its dining room, this is a real cost. Image expansion has generated ceiling that was never there, and on one storefront photo, a second doorway.
Meta's defaults will spend your $20 a day two hundred miles from your front door, and the account will look fine while it happens.
Turn off anything that changes your message or your image: text improvements, image template, expand image, 3D animation, music. Check three places while you're there, because switching one off at the ad level leaves it on in Business Settings under Advertising Settings, and catalog ads carry a third set of toggles inside catalog settings.
There is a second reason to care. Meta has been attaching an AI label to ads it reads as AI-generated or AI-edited, and I went through what that label does to a local ad in July. Letting Meta's own tools rewrite your storefront photo is a strange way to end up wearing it.
Are you accidentally in a special ad category?
If your ad mentions hiring, housing, credit, or financing, Meta requires you to declare a special ad category. Most owners find this out after Meta flags an ad.
The categories catch ordinary shops:
- A restaurant boosting a "now hiring servers" post is employment.
- A furniture store advertising 0% for twelve months is credit.
- A property manager posting an available unit is housing.
Declaring it costs you your targeting. In the US, Meta holds housing, employment and credit ads to a minimum 15-mile radius, with no zip code targeting, no age or gender selection, no lookalike audiences, and no detailed targeting exclusions. That 15-mile floor traces back to the Justice Department's 2022 settlement with Meta over discriminatory ad delivery.
Run the math before you write the ad. A barbershop in Speedway that wants to hire one barber cannot advertise that job to Speedway. It advertises to roughly half of Marion County at a 15-mile minimum, and pays for all of it. For a single hire, a sign in the window and a post on your Google Business Profile will usually cost less than the wasted reach.
Set a spending limit before you set a budget
Ads Manager, then Billing, then Payment settings, then Account spending limit. Do this before you set a campaign budget.
A daily budget is not a ceiling on what Meta can charge you. Meta can spend up to 25% over your daily number on a strong day and balance it back across the week. A campaign left running through Labor Day weekend does not know you meant to pause it on Friday. An account spending limit stops delivery at a hard figure, and it is the only number in the account that Meta cannot exceed.
Set it at one month of intended spend. If you plan on $600, set $600 and re-set it monthly.
Ads Manager is counting results you didn't get
The default attribution setting is 7-day click plus 1-day view. The second half counts people who saw your ad, never clicked it, and converted within a day anyway.
For a national brand running retargeting, that assumption is defensible. For a chiropractor in Zionsville whose conversion is a form fill, it pads the number you use to decide next month's budget. Set the window to 7-day click for your first month. Your reported results will drop. Your actual results will not move, and you will finally be comparing your spend against something you can trust.
Does the new Meta location fee hit an Indianapolis shop?
No, and it is worth saying plainly because the coverage has been muddy.
Meta started applying a location fee of 2% to 5% on ad spend in July: 5% for Austria and Türkiye, 3% for France, Italy and Spain, 2% for the United Kingdom. I wrote up the fee and where Meta buried it when it landed.
The fee follows where the ad is delivered, not where your business sits. A shop targeting fifteen miles around Fishers pays nothing extra. The only local businesses it touches are the ones running ads at customers or family overseas, and there are more of those in Indianapolis than most people would guess.
The budget math for one location
Start at $20 a day. One campaign, one ad set, three creatives. That is $600 a month, and it is enough to learn something.
The reason to run one ad set instead of four is arithmetic. Meta's ad sets need roughly 50 optimization events per week to leave the learning phase, and delivery stays volatile until they do. If you optimize for leads and a lead costs $18, that is $900 a week to get there. A shop spending $140 a week will never reach it.
You have two honest ways through that.
| Approach | What you optimize for | Weekly events at $20/day | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Optimize for leads | Form fills or calls | 7 or 8 | Never exits learning phase |
| Optimize higher up | Link clicks or landing page views | 200+ | Exits in days |
| Split into 4 ad sets | Anything, at $5/day each | Under 3 each | Guarantees nothing learns |
Optimize for clicks or landing page views at this budget and let volume do the teaching. Then judge the campaign on a 30-day window instead of a 7-day one, which you should be doing regardless. I have already made the case for leaving ads alone past day seven, and it applies double when your ad set is still learning.
The seven settings, in order
| # | Setting | Where | Change it to |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Location type and radius | Ad set, Audience | People living in this location, radius set by drive time |
| 2 | Advantage+ audience controls | Ad set, Audience | Minimum age and exclusions set deliberately |
| 3 | Placements | Ad set, Placements | Manual after two weeks if Audience Network underperforms |
| 4 | Creative enhancements | Ad level and Business Settings | Off for text, template, expand image, animation, music |
| 5 | Special ad category | Campaign | Declared honestly, budget adjusted for the 15-mile floor |
| 6 | Account spending limit | Billing, Payment settings | One month of intended spend |
| 7 | Attribution window | Ad set, Optimization | 7-day click for the first month |
One thing before you fund the account. If your Google Business Profile is half empty, paid ads are an expensive way to fix a free problem, and your profile beats your website for anyone searching your shop by name. Fill that in first. If you would rather hand the whole thing over, that is part of what we do, though I would rather you spent the hour and kept the money.
The salon in Avon runs $20 a day now. One ad set, one mile, people who live in Avon. Same photos, same copy, nothing rewritten. Her cost per lead went from $53 to $19.
The only thing that changed was an hour of checkboxes.
Sources
| # | Source | What it backed up |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | About Advantage+ audience | The split between hard audience controls (location, language, minimum age, exclusions) and suggestions (age range, gender, detailed targeting). |
| 2 | What turns Advantage+ on and off | Advantage+ audience and placements being enabled by default on new campaigns. |
| 3 | Turn off Advantage+ creative enhancements | The enhancement list and the three separate places the toggles live. |
| 4 | About the learning phase | The roughly 50 optimization events per ad set per week needed to exit the learning phase. |
| 5 | How to choose a Special Ad Category | Which ads must be declared, and the targeting removed once they are. |
| 6 | Justice Department settlement with Meta Platforms | The 2022 settlement behind the US targeting floor on housing, employment and credit ads. |